I Ate Meat on Friday During Lent. Is That a Sin?

It’s Friday during Lent. You forget and eat a burger.
Or your child’s birthday falls on Good Friday.
Or you’re holding a slice of pizza thinking, “Wait… did I just commit a mortal sin?”

In this episode, Nicole walks through what the Church actually asks of us during Lent — and what it doesn’t.

We cover:

• What Catholics are required to do on Fridays in Lent
• The difference between forgetting and deliberately rejecting Church teaching
• What fasting and abstinence are really about
• How to handle a Good Friday birthday
• Why Lent is about freedom, not fear

If you’re new to the Church, raising kids, or trying to live Lent faithfully in a world that doesn’t observe it, this conversation is for you.

The framework is simple:
Put Christ first. Then celebrate freely.

Catechism references mentioned:
CCC 1438
CCC 2043
CCC 1857

Stay connected: 

Rebel Saints Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/rebelsaintspodcast/

Rebel Saints Facebook Community: https://www.facebook.com/groups/rebelsaintspodcast

Rebel Saints Facebook Page: https://www.facebook.com/RebelSaintsPodcast

Rebel Saints TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@rebelsaintspodcast

Rebel Saints Substack: https://substack.com/@rebelsaints

This episode was written and produced by Nicole Olea

If you enjoyed this show, please leave a review or share it with a friend. 

Got questions?
Email us at rebelsaintspodcast@gmail.com

Connect with us: 

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/rebelsaintspodcast/

Facebook Community: https://www.facebook.com/groups/rebelsaintspodcast

Facebook Page: https://www.facebook.com/RebelSaintsPodcast

TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@rebelsaintspodcast

Blog: https://substack.com/@rebelsaints

For exclusive content join our Patreon page for free: https://patreon.com/RebelSaintsPodcast

Music featured in this podcast, is used under Upbeat's license terms for creators. Music is human-made, rights-cleared for podcasts and content creators. 

Main theme song  "Life Mood" by Daniel Hartmann can be found at Upbeat - https://share.uppbeat.io/7lal9g5wpyks

License code: SUWF2L8VG76UJDZS

Music on this podcast may also be sourced from pixabay

Transcript

Hello, you faithful misfits. Welcome back to Rebel Saints. I’m Nicole. I’m your host.

Today I want to talk about something that, on the surface, might not seem like a big theological issue. But if you’re raising children like I am — or honestly, if you’re just trying to live Lent well — you’ll eventually run into moments like this.

Picture it.

It’s a Friday during Lent. You’re at a celebration. Maybe it’s someone’s birthday at work. Maybe you’re at the bowling alley talking to another parent. Someone hands you a plate. You take the burger. Or the salami and crackers. You’re halfway through when it hits you.

Gosh darn it. It’s Friday.

Or maybe this scenario feels more familiar.

Your child’s birthday falls on Good Friday.

You’re staring at the calendar thinking: What am I supposed to do? Do we celebrate? Do we postpone? Do we ignore the birthday altogether? What does faithfulness actually look like here? Where are the instructions?

On a personal note, I have two children whose birthdays fall right around Holy Week. We’ve had years planning cake and family dinners while preparing for the Triduum. We’ve had Friday birthday invitations during Lent. And yes, there are those internal questions: Are we being too relaxed? Are we being too rigid? What does the Church actually ask of us?

Let’s clear something up.

I have never once thought I couldn’t celebrate my child’s birthday simply because it fell during Lent. Now, if it fell on Good Friday? That requires more discernment. But if you’re new to the Church — or if this is your first Lent taking it seriously — these questions make sense.

Are we allowed to celebrate?
Are we allowed to feel joy during Lent?

If you’re asking those questions, it doesn’t mean you’re scrupulous. If you’re not asking them, it doesn’t mean you’re less holy. It just means you’re living real life.

So let’s talk about what the Church actually requires.

The Catechism of the Catholic Church, paragraph 1438, says:

“The seasons and days of penance in the course of the liturgical year (Lent, and each Friday in memory of the death of the Lord) are intense moments of the Church’s penitential practice.”

Friday is not random. It is the day our Lord gave His life for us. Every Friday carries the memory of Calvary.

Then paragraph 2043 tells us:

“You shall observe the days of fasting and abstinence established by the Church.”

Why? As a form of penance. To prepare us for feasts. To help us gain mastery over our instincts. To acquire what the Catechism calls “freedom of heart.”

Freedom of heart.

That’s the goal.

The Church asks us to fast and abstain so we are not ruled by appetite, convenience, or impulse. Discipline trains love. And love requires self-mastery.

Here’s the actual discipline:

On Fridays during Lent, Catholics age fourteen and older abstain from meat.
On Ash Wednesday and Good Friday, Catholics ages eighteen to fifty-nine fast and abstain.

Fasting means one normal meal and two smaller meals that together don’t equal a second full meal. You are still eating. No one is asking you to starve.

Now here’s something equally important.

Paragraph 1857 of the Catechism reminds us that for a sin to be mortal, three conditions must be present: grave matter, full knowledge, and deliberate consent.

If you forgot it was Friday and ate meat unintentionally, that is not deliberate rejection. The Church does not bind consciences where there was no free and knowing choice.

Life is busy. You’re juggling work, school schedules, parish commitments, sports practices. You’re somewhere you normally wouldn’t be. Your brain thinks it’s Saturday.

You take a bite of the burger.

In that moment, you have a choice.

You can spiral. Or you can respond as a son or daughter of God.

A simple prayer:
“Lord, I’m sorry. Help me be more attentive.”

And you move forward.

Saint Francis de Sales often guided souls who struggled with scrupulosity. He warned that excessive anxiety over small, unintended faults does not come from God. God is a Father. He is not waiting for you to slip so He can trap you.

Lent is about purification — not panic.

If your heart wants to make a small act of love the next day — a simpler meal, an extra prayer — that’s beautiful. But you are not required to invent penalties out of fear.

Now let’s talk about the harder scenario.

A birthday on Good Friday.

Good Friday is the most solemn day of the year. Altars are stripped. The Church is silent. We venerate the Cross. We fast. We remember the suffering and death of Jesus Christ.

And then you look at your seven-year-old and realize it’s their birthday.

Here’s how we’ve handled it in our family.

You don’t ignore Good Friday.
And you don’t ignore your child.

You honor the order of love.

Saint Augustine taught that sin is disordered love — loving good things in the wrong order. A child’s birthday is a very good thing. But Good Friday is about the salvation of the world.

So we keep the day solemn. We attend liturgy. We fast. We pray.

Then we celebrate at the right time.

Maybe the party moves to Holy Saturday evening. Maybe it moves into the Easter Octave. Maybe Good Friday itself is simple — a quiet prayer of thanksgiving for your child’s life.

You can look at them and say:
“Your birthday will always be near the day Jesus gave everything for us.”

That doesn’t diminish them. It anchors them.

And remember — children under fourteen are not bound to fast or abstain. You can decide how to teach this in your home. Maybe there’s a small treat. Maybe you save the big celebration. It’s your family.

The goal of Lent is not suppressing joy.

It’s purifying it.

Fasting helps us gain freedom of heart. It teaches us we are not ruled by appetite or anxiety. We are ruled by love.

Saint Thérèse of Lisieux said:
“Perfection consists in doing His will, in being what He wills us to be.”

She’s not describing flawlessness. She’s describing loving obedience.

Sometimes that means kneeling in silence.
Sometimes it means moving the birthday party.
Sometimes it means humbly admitting you forgot it was Friday.

That’s how we grow up spiritually.

If I give you anything to reflect on this week, read Catechism paragraphs 1438, 1857, and 2043 slowly.

Examine your heart.

Do you approach Church discipline with resentment? Fear? Or love?

If you’re new to the Church, here’s the simplest framework:

Put Christ first.
Then celebrate freely.

That’s how we rebels live.

Let’s pray.

Lord Jesus,
You gave everything for us on the Cross.
Teach us to honor Your Passion without fear.
Give us discipline that leads to freedom.
Give us joy that is rightly ordered.
Help us raise our families anchored in Your Cross and confident in Your mercy.
Amen.

If this episode helped you think more clearly about living Lent — as a family or as someone navigating a world that doesn’t observe it — I want to invite you into this mission.

Please subscribe so you don’t miss what’s coming next. Leave a review — not for my ego — but because it helps other Catholics find encouragement in the middle of trying to live this faith seriously.

Follow us on social media. All the links are in the show notes.

From the bottom of my heart, thank you for listening to Rebel Saints.

Until next time:

Be bold.
Be holy.
Be a Rebel Saint.